📰 New article from TorrentFreak
Judge Won’t Let ‘DMCA-Ignored’ Host Use Cox Ruling to Escape $42m Judgment
https://torrentfreak.com/judge-wont-let-dmca-ignored-host-use-cox-ruling-to-escape-42m-judgment/
If you thought your inbox was a mess, try managing 500 ignored DMCA takedown notices. That was the exact headache DISH Network faced with Virtual Systems (VSYS Host), a company that famously marketed itself as a “DMCA-ignored” haven for pirate IPTV services.
Fast forward to now: the $41.85 million judgment against them is standing firm.
The hosting company tried a classic legal “Hail Mary,” hoping a recent Supreme Court ruling regarding Cox Communications would provide a loophole to escape the massive fine. They argued that the law had shifted, making them less liable for the piracy happening on their servers.
The judge, however, wasn’t buying it. She pointed out a few glaring issues:
- The “Cox” defense didn’t fit: The new ruling didn’t actually change the rules regarding “vicarious liability,” which is the core of DISH’s case.
- Too little, too late: The defendants waited five months to act and offered zero explanation for the delay.
- The “Seattle” mystery: While the host claimed they had no U.S. servers left, DISH provided evidence that their server locations seemed to “migrate” to Ukraine right as the lawsuit heated up.
Ultimately, the court ruled that you can’t just ignore legal notices and then hope for a change in the law to save your bank account.
